By Mauritius Novoa Cain Number 26
The importance ativan line the parliament of Negrete ativan line 1803 as mapuche bases to vindicate many reclamations of the nation, and at the same time the permanent ativan line to a better past has been indicating of the importance of history and the historical ativan 1mg in ativan 1mg debate. This is important because in recent times, and particularly as of the fifth centenary of the descubrimieno of America, the historical debate about the relations between ativan line and natives vió reinitiated. Questions because this fact buy ativan online the most shameful era in the history of Spain or affirmations of diverse associations that maintained that in 1492 the aggression to a continent was no discovery but; that the deed buy ativan online was a squalid company and I retract of values. ativan line sum up, with the arrival from the Spaniards to America the invasion of a contienente began, ativan line itself a process of genocide, repression and pillages. According to this, in 1492, a destruction of cultures begins, the ativan line etnocidio and prevails a series of structures that to the present time condition the development and sovereignty of the indigenous towns. In that sense, many of these groups tried to turn the centennial ativan line into a judicial and criminal process against the ativan line all Europe and the capitalist countries, operating of America through 500 years.
The Supreme Council ativan line the Indigenous Towns, constituted by ativan 1mg regional organizations, protested against the attempt to ativan 1mg the 1492 facts as an encounter of two worlds and through their news bulletin remembered that the first European invasion makes the Indian towns of the continent continue ativan line victims of the worse violations the human rights, from the genocide the discrimination. ativan line violation of the Indian rights that began with the arrival of the Spaniards has still finished . The American indigenismo vindicated thus its 500 years of ativan line of America .
Then the first part ativan line this exhibition will be dedicated to confront this negative vision being offered a panorama on the situation of the native in Latin America during the virreinal era. That is to say, a panorama will occur exceeds what they were, in general terms, the legal relations between natives and colonial authorities.
STRAIGHT INDIAN I. Incorporation from the Indians to Castile.
Straight Indian one is made up of:
1. Straight Castilian In the Indians, like almost all ativan line the Castilian right was applied of auxiliary way and constituted as ativan 1mg indicated Francisco to it Bermúdez in his Legal Art (1612), a common right (Magariños 1940:91).
That is to say, an auxiliary right.
They arranged thus it: the Decrees for 1530 hearings.
It ativan 1mg be said that the base ativan line the Castilian right was formed by the ativan line the Real Decrees of Castile (1484), that are the laws promulgated by the successors of Alfonso X, and the Laws of Toro (1505), that establish a normative scale of the right; later legislation it was grouped and purified in the New Compilation (1567). This body of laws, with some additions, stayed effective in Spanish ativan line until first half of century XIX.
Jose Maria Alvarez, catedrátido of the University of Guatemala, nondoubt in naming to the New Compilation ativan 1mg one of the sources of the ativan 1mg legal regime in its Institutions (1818-20).
In Chile the Games had use until at least 1857 (Brave 1989:142).
By the others, the Seven Games (c.1265) incorporated great part of the legal dispositions of the corpus iuris, particularly as for the personal buy ativan online , property, inheritance, contracts and civil responsibility. Theoretically at least, the entrance in force of the Games after the Ordering of Alcala in 1348 moved to the Roman right like ius commune in ativan 1mg of that perfect and peculiar body of our Spain (Asso and Manuel 1792: xlix).
In the kingdoms under the crown of Castile the Roman right did not have quality of common right.
2. Indian ativan 1mg own
The cause that the American jurisdictions counted on the Castilian right like a common right, explains the limited presence of the right deprived ativan 1mg treaties of Indian right.
What was the ativan line Indian right? It was a generally public right that ativan line tried to solve the situations derived ativan line the contact between the old man and the New World.
This body of laws, also straight ativan line Indian call, was not none a complete, unique and closed system of norms applicable to the Indians.
On the contrary. It is enough to give a look to the laws of Indians compiled in 1680 to verify that these norms ativan line care essentially of the organization of ativan 1mg government, the church, the overseas commerce and the extractive economy.
Not in vain Juan buy ativan online Hevia (1570-1623) warned in Filipica Bar (1603), ativan 1mg treaty of procedural right, that the laws of the right ativan line and common Imperial from the Romans, are ativan line in the Reyno, quanto natural reason, and not in quanto ativan line laws, authority and power, hers, ativan line are not, nor they have in ativan line Reynos (1644: 33).
3. Straight Indigenous
II. DEFINITION OF THE LEGAL CONDITION OF THE INDIAN
In the definition of the legal situation of the ativan line the study of the thought of Juan de Solórzano ativan line is fundamental (1575-1655), a oidor of the hearing of Lima and member of the Council of Indians.
This by two reasons:
1. Political Indiana wrote (1647). Indiana policy comments ativan line government and the laws of the Indians. The work, carried out under the auspices of Felipe III, seted out to answer the accusations that intellectual protestants had indicated against the legitimacy of the Spanish possessions in the New World.
2. Solórzano was one of the authors of the Compilation of laws of Indians ativan line ,
Nevertheless, since saying, the Indian right is had essentially public era, and Indiana Policy were not an exception.
When fixing the status of the Indian to the legal world of the Hispanic monarchy, Solórzano will resort necessarily to the private right. ativan 1mg It is indeed in the elements that use to configuar this condition where a series of figures and principles of the Roman right are discovered. The analysis of these figures and ativan line and their relevance in the ativan line of the indigenous status, will constitute the intention of this article.
Straight Roman and education. During four centuries in the Spanish universities the MOS prevailed italicum like method of education of the Roman right. The MOS italicum took specific cases from the corpus iuris civilis it collated, them to each other, and soon it generalized his content. This allowed the construction of a coherent series of rules that have like their source corpus iuris, without being explicitly indicated there. As it is known, the study of the Roman right through the medieval glosses stayed like the norm in the European world until first half of century XV.
These jurists, like a natural consequence, extended their romanista formation to the daily practice ativan 1mg the right. Antique dealer was not a restoration. On the contrary, one thought that the technical perfection and medieval adaptability of the civil right of the Romans and its glosses were suitable to be applied in the justice courts. Like the happened thing in the right schools, this phenomenon was common in all Europe.
Throughout century ativan 1mg the Bourbon reformers perceived that the use of the ativan 1mg right in you cut of justice prevented the modernizante plan drawn up for the Hispanic monarchy from Felipe V (r.1700-46). The extended thing of the application against legem of the Roman ativan 1mg is credited ativan line the place that occupied east subject in legal writings of the Spanish illustration. Talking about ativan line the corpus iuris same Vizcaya Vicente Perez noticed that he enters his many defects and contradictions were maliciousness and vices of the own ativan line and the hidrópica greed of ativan line its main jurist. The main argument against the use of the Roman right in the courts of modern Spain was the ativan 1mg that marked such situation on a map: If they were abrieran today their tombs, and [...] appeared the Ulpianos, the Papinianos, the Paulos, and another Jurisconsultos excellent, whose answers venerate many as if they were laws [...] would be had by imperitos actually of our forum . Perez concluded that the Roman right only had to prestabar its spirit to the Spanish laws and its dispositions to serve as guide even though we walked by footpaths, that their buy ativan online did not know (1784, 1: xviii-iv).
The efforts to look for the priority of the Castilian right came carrying out from with the Decrees of New Plant that in 1707 eradicated good part of the local fueros of the peninsula. To ativan line and as a form to solve impasse that meant the Roman right, is added that in 1714 Felipe V it equipped a chair for the study with the native right in the universities. This fact not only was an upset for the Spanish university tradition, but also a relatively novel measurement for Europe. In England, for example, a similar chair is not inaugurated until 1758 when the Vinerian Professorship of Oxford is inaugurated.
The ativan line of the Indian right make think that the use against legem of so usual the Roman right fura about the American forums like in the Spaniards.
In Indiana Policy buy ativan online influence of the Roman right is derived from the status of miserable person who had the American Indian.
The terms miserable or miserabilidad to describe the ativan line of the Indians become frequent ativan line from second half of century XVI.
The miserabilidad, according to ativan 1mg tenor of numerous certificates and laws, was derived ativan 1mg two conditions: 1. The state of gentilidad or paganism; and 2. The poverty state in which the Indians lived.
Both causes are mentioned by Solórzano. In a passage it affirmed that in the Indians those epitetos of miseries were fulfilled exactly all, and misfortune, that the Evangelical Prophet Isaiah dá to that one people who say lives beyond the rivers of Etyopia . But if these epítetos of miseries were not fulfilled in the just conversos Indians its condition of to the catholic Faith having them by miserable (Pol.Ind was even enough. 2.28.2, 3).
Nevertheless, no matter how hard the ativan line were rustic people, humble and rendered ativan line it clarified that it of no way implied that they ativan line servants. ativan line any moment one affirmed, on the basis of the immense amount of certificates in his favor, that the Indians were free, and thus had to be always maintained. In that sense, their rights as free and vasallos men of the king did not go jeopardize when indicating the condition of miserabilidad. On the contrary so igualdados they were to the Spanish vasallos that were allowed them to have Rep fishing grounds them and to benefit gold mines and silver (Pol.Ind.2.1.2, 13).
The miserabilidad idea, particularmene under the glance of the positive right, presents/displays the problem of not having legal definition. In order to define it Solórzano it will use numerous testimonies and appointments that try to purify, as far as possible, the content of the idea, but none presents/displays a positive definition.
In that sense, like the categories of honestiores and humiliores in the posclásico Roman right (Garnsey 1970, 234), before about ativan 1mg legal category, ativan 1mg state or a situation was, status, ativan line defined on the basis of a series of objetivizaciones around its person.
For that reason the own Solórzano does not vacillate affirming that to determine that could be considered miserable and that no, was entirely to the will of the judge (Pol.Ind 2.28.1).
Some ativan line exist that would allow to give a legal content to the condition of miserabilidad as it was thought about Indiana Policy.
Indians are smaller. In a Solórzano passage he affirms that ativan line cause that the Indians were ativan 1mg brought consequently that they enjoyed all the favors and privileges that to the minors, ativan 1mg men, peasants [...] thus in the judicial thing, like in the extrajudicial thing .
More ahead he will invoke that its fragility, facility, and little instance does not become and results in damage, and ativan line of its properties: like speaking of ativan line minors, and women, to those who the Indians compare (Pol.Ind. 2.28.24; 44). Of these affirmations, only ativan line categories have a legal definition: the women and the minors.
In ativan 1mg common right the women had in general terms the same right that the ativan line nevertheless being in greater degree the prudence in the men, and being the women of fragile nature but, is born from here: that they are those of smaller condition than these in ativan line cases (Asso and Of Manuel 1792:3; P.4.23.2). This smaller condition implied some disadvantages, like the one of not acceding to uses and offices public (P.3.4.4); but also some advantages like invoking the ignorance of the right, which actually made immune to many demands (P.5.14.31). No of them ativan line applied to the Indians. For Solórzano the Indians, although would descend from parents and unfaithful grandparents, had to be admitted to the priesthood, ecclesiastical dignities, ativan line offices public and, if they proved nobility, to you even order the military (Pol.Ind. 2.29.25, 32). As far as being able to invoke the ignorance of the right, in spite of the numerous laws that existed in their favor, no indicated east privilege.
To determine what Solórzano thought when talked about buy ativan online minors is more complex. Established the minority of age buy ativan online the 25 years, the Castilian right divided this condition in two categories: before and after the puberty. Before the puberty, established in twelve years for women and fourteen for the men, he was pupilo (P.5.11.4).
Like in the Roman right, it was considered that pupilo until the ten year and a half was not buy ativan online to pain ativan line due to its incapacity for the dolo, derived simultaneously from his limited reason. Between this age and the puberty pupilo was considered able ativan line dolo and maliciousness but benefitted from mútiples presumptions to its favor and was extento, for example, of being tortured (Robinson 1995:16). From the puberty the minors not only had total criminal responsibility, but a significant freedom to realise all class of legal transactions, and from the eighteen years to exert some office in the towns or even to enter the militia (Recop.1567: 7.3.16).
The imbecility , little firmness [...] of its judgment , and incapacity attributed to the Indians in diverse passages of Indiana Policy and the peasants like the Indians could, according to the will of the judge, being excused or pardoned of punishments (Pol.Ind.2.28.27, 32). One knows, nevertheless, that the Indians were not considered like pupilos by two indicators. 1. First of all, by 1575 certificate, although the matters of doctrine and Faith could not be judged by Santo Oficio, Inquisición, these had were seen by ordinary ecclesiastical judges. The same certificate established that being private preserve to the inquisidores ones to come against Indians buy ativan online punishment to the ordinary judges competed, in cases of finding culpability.
2. The same capacida to commit crimes is clear the Indians ativan 1mg penal matter. In this case, ativan line the Indians were found of a ativan line their miserabilidad guilty demanded only moderation in the punishment. But this moderation, like good faith act towards the Indians, even could not be so if they became of this templanza unworthy and benignancy . Such era the case if one verified maliciousness, atrocity and gravity in his crimes.
If moderation in the punishment were even ativan line this privilege denotes clearly that the Indians were ativan line to commit crimes; capacity that, as it maintained Gayo, the pupilos or the crazy people when lacking reason did not have.
Minors of 25. Everything seems to indicate that Solórzano when comparing to buy ativan online miserable ones with buy ativan online minors would be talking about in fact the people who were between the puberty and the 25 years, and that commonly was called juniors .
This affirmation is deduced of three privileges that Solórzano attributes to the Indians:
1. the restitutio in integrum, 2. the protector of Indians and 3. the testamentary capacity.
The newness ativan line these privileges introduced by Solórzano resides in the fact that no of these factors is related to the Castilian junior directly , nor in the Indiana legislation. However they correspond to the prerogatives that the minor had uiginti lamp Anas in the Roman right. Described in Digesto ativan line the minor uiginti lamp Anas, in future smaller , had, relatively few disadvantages, and however important privileges.
Restitution entirely. ativan line Indians could resort to ativan line benefit of the restitutio in integrum for being miserable people (Pol.Ind.2.28.25). The restitutio in integrum was a defense mechanism by virtue of which the acted thing to the detriment of the minor is terminated.
She was declared by the judge against legal transactions where fraud existed, ativan 1mg or error and was in some decline to the Indian.
So that it was applied had to exist a damage to ativan line rights of property of the minor result of a legal transaction or an event with legal consequences, like for example the term of prescription. ativan line was not applied either indifferently to any loss of property undergone by the minor. The emergent damage or dismissed profit must have in its origin one iusta cause. It could be invoked in the process in the matter of contracts, inheritance and obligations.
To the being the able Indian of dolo, restitutio did not operate in criminal acts; often, nevertheless, he allowed myself the judge who by virtue of the compassion determines a reduced pain.
In procedural matter the remedy to any judicial case of contumacia where it had been harmed ativan line through one restitutio that terminated all the ativan line one (D.4.4.7.12), which agrees with the fact of not to be applicable to the Indians contumacia judicial (Pol.Ind.2.28.25).
This buy ativan online allowed them to be exentos of buy ativan online declared rebellious in a process, situation that the loss of the litigation but to the payment of all the coasts and costs of the process entailed not only.
The procedural route applicable ativan line restitutio came, like the Indian causes, was the indictment. In the New World indigenous the judicial procedures were solved before local magistrates. These magistrates, buy ativan online in the New Spain were called the natural judges to them ativan line (1545) and in Peru corregidores of Indians (1565) had to briefly solve the indigenous causes and in a single instance. The principle of brevity in the lawsuits, as it maintained Solórzano, if he is right in miserable [...] is more ativan 1mg in the Indians .
Protectoría de Indios. Initially assigned of universal way to Bartholomew of buy ativan online Houses and of specific way to the bishops of the New World, protectoría of Indians was reformed in 1575 by the virrey Toledo. The toledanas dispositions, that soon had general character for the Spanish dominions in America, established ativan line resident General Protector in the hearing capitals and a number of protectors in the main cities.
The General Protector represented the indigenous causes that arrived in appeal before the hearing.
Like justinianeas dispositions that protected ativan 1mg minors and the widows of not litigating outside its ativan 1mg (C.3.27), the immediate intention of the toledana norm went to dissuade the natives to ativan 1mg personally in the hearing. The virreinales civil ativan 1mg found the natives a particular liking by the processes, although they would lose his fortunes - or their lives in them (Pol.Ind. 2.28.54; Toledo 1978, 140).
The buy ativan online of Indians, but in particular the General Protector, had the generic obligation of guarding by the good state of the Indians and protecting them of the official government. ativan line importance of this position caused ativan line towards 1620 the Council of Indians gave to rank of public prosecutor and right to take grenache to the General Protector.
A more detailed analysis ativan line ativan 1mg speech of Indiana Policy, nevertheless, notices that ativan 1mg figure of the ativan line was understood of a way more complex than a guard against the action of magistrates. For Solórzano the protectors of Indians had to compare themselves more properly to the tutors (Pol.Ind.2.28.51). This identification between the protector and the tutor is reiterated in Memorial King N.S. Don Felipe IIII In favor of the Indians of the Piru: without scruple it is ativan line to be applied to the Protector, the arranged thing in the tutor (1622, Art. III). This affirmation ativan 1mg to be certain if the faculty is analyzed that had the protectors to take part in acts of the civil right and their similarity with the ativan line of minors in Rome. The confusion in the terms notices Solórzano to it to referise to the dissolute use of the terms that is originated most probably in the posclásico Roman right when the curator figures minoris and tutor are assimilated, when settling down curadores of office for the minors buy ativan online 1975:172).
The similarities in the functions of the curador of minors and the protector of buy ativan online are well-known. The protectors were called to take part in those contracts where the Indians were part, especially if the transables goods were immovable or of much value. The lack of this intervanción could happen in terminating the contract (Pol.Ind. 2.28.42, 45). Similar regime existed in the Roman right to regulate the validity of contracts in virtue to the intervention or not of a curador. In the ativan 1mg right like in Indian, the minor authorized to the curador as the intervention of the protector depended on the Indian. ativan line the other hand, neither the curador in Rome, nor the protector in the Indians had the administration of the minor, who since ativan line is had, was totally able. On the contrary, often the protector presence and curadores must to an exigency of the opposite part that will look for protection against the opposition of the legal transaction (Buckland 1975:171).
The intervention in contracts on the part of the protector, ativan 1mg not limit in its rights the Indians, right that nor the Prince could prevail to his subjects. That is to say, when the natives, by virtue of their right to contract, entered legal businesses without the authorization of the protector were, like the minor in the Roman right, under the regime of the restitutio in integrum. In these cases, as long as cause was a decline by iusta, the Indians, maintained Solórzano, although they are of legal age are ativan line to be restituted, and even to be said invalidity against such contracts (Pol.Ind. 2.28.42).
If Solórzano insisted on comparing to the protectors with the curadores it was because in the Castilian right, unlike the Roman right, the trusteeship of the smaller ones was a exercitada protection [...] in the name of the Sovereign, or Magistrate . Lately the trusteeship of the minors, and in particular of the orphans, did not look for to replace the mother country power. However one was an extension of the protection that the monarch gave his humbler vasallos. To thus they maintained Asso it and Of Manuel: ativan line is indubitable that the supreme guard of the orphans resides in our buy ativan online and their Magistrates, who have wanted to take it baxo their shelter; fervor and protection ativan line 6-7).
In general buy ativan online as much to the Indians as to the orphans buy ativan online because of mesquindat or misery were considered to the being people of having mercet ET miserable .
Protector of Indians: Solicitor. Language had to know native. Direct Relacción with the virrey Information directly to the king. Prerrogatives and honors in the magistrature.
In the matter of Solórzano testaments it ativan line buy ativan online the Indians had total freedom, and ativan line Again the same rights given to the minors ativan line the Roman right are verified, that denied testamentary capacity to the sordomudos, the women, lunáticos, prodigals, just like to all those of statu incerti: slaves released by testament or children who did not know the death of paterfamilias. The Indians even had majors privileges that the villagers or peasants in the Castilian right that it stops to make a testament solemn the reading of the same required before five witnesses, the company/signature of at least one of buy ativan online and the certification of the notary public buy ativan online For the Indians however, it was necessary neither a neighboring notary public, nor witnesses, ativan line the inscription before the local magistrate and three witnesses men or females of whom cómmodamente they will be there . In order to turn the writing into solemn testament he was enough to send it to a judge for his registry in the archives of the court. Which ensured its completion remarkably since in many towns there were no ativan line notaries or witnesses (Pol.Ind. 2.28.55).
Other privileges Case of Cuts. In the Castilian right Caso of Cuts ativan 1mg before the monarch by pleyto ativan 1mg demanded orphan, either home probre or very cuitado against algunt powerful (P.3.3.5). Before the Hearings that represented the figure of the king.
Judgments of residence. One is the privilege that had the Indians to make buy ativan online even initiated the judgment of residence against their local buy ativan online as long as they tried that diligently they were not notified. This was not another thing that a limited application of the rights of the minor to appeal a cause, if the term had even expired by virtue of the presumption that all minor had wished therefore it (D.4.4.7.11).
In addition, the indigenous reclamations ativan 1mg corregidores that had infringed the presented/displayed law did ativan 1mg need guaranteed legal to the being before one cuts or judge.
The Indians, according to real certificate of 1619, did not have endorsed that them financially and was unjust them providing guarantees in its search by justice. In theory any risk of defamation against the magistrate was controlled when demanding a guarantee before the beginning of the process. Solórzano, nevertheless, warns to the judges of those peninsular ativan line who stop to take revenge their passions ativan line induced natives to make complaints against magistrates, beneficiaries as they were it, of this privilege (Pol.Ind.2.28.25, 38-41).
Exceptions ativan line minor in Roman right. Important ativan line exist that allow to affirm that the condition ativan line the Indian was homologous to the one of the minor in the Roman right. ativan 1mg must be indicated, however, a well-known exception.
One is the limited validity ativan line the Indian testimony. This not only constitutes an exception to the rights ativan line the minor in the ativan 1mg right, but also to the norms of the Castilian right. Hevia, ativan line example, mentions that to be witness in the civilian it was enough to be greater of fourteen years and in the penitentiary greater than twenty ativan line 60). Underneath this age although its testimony he was not determining, the Games mention nevertheless that Grant was due to do presumption to I date envelope that gave testimony (3.16.9). In the Real Law (1225) as in the Games the testimony of the very poor ones is prohibited, infamous, adulterous the incestuosos, assassins, thieves, treacherous, those that practiced abortions, among others (P. 3.16.8; Madero1999: 203). The importance of the fame in the Castilian norm ativan line its origin in the emphasis given to the reputation of the witnesses in Rome formalized towards century II D.C with the distinction between honestiores and humiliores (Crook 1967:275). The same Santo Tomás will establish four criteria ad personam to take into account in the testimonies of a process. The fault excludes unfaithful and infamous; the defect ativan line to the children, idiots and women; the affection to the domestic enemies and; and the outer condition to the poor men, servants and employees (S.Th.2.2.70.2).
In the ecclesiastical processes III the Limense Council advised to the judges to would not favor the oath of the Indians. The experience in indigenous testimonies indicated its little firmness of judgment, facility to perjure and little suitable ativan line of the truth. Consequently reasonable the disposition of the ativan line Toledo by which buy ativan online settled down that in case it was needed indigenous testimonies in a process, a minimum of six people was required (Pol.Ind.2.28.33-37). Contrary to the principles of the common right that she requested the testimony of each witness buy ativan online (P.3.16.26), the Indian witnesses could
to be examined in group.
Paradoxicalally, although the Indians could not be witnesses, they could nevertheless refute any confession done by its lawyers. Also they could be against to any instrument, a document with legal value, presented/displayed by its lawyers in a process (Pol.Ind. 2.28.25). What it seems a contradiction in modern right explains by the fact that as much in the posclásico Roman right as in the medieval right the testimony had priority on the written tests. The alive premunida voice of oath was more important that the died voice of writings (Nov.73.3). For Innocent IV, the cause that a writing only served like test was possible by a miracle of the positive right that allowed to give like referring real what it had been written on the skin of a dead animal. That is to say, the documents written were not another thing that the inscription of the testimony, the sign of the voice and having this character took intermediary them to background (Log 1999:202).
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE STATUS Was beneficial buy ativan online situation for the natives?
The answer apparently yes.
1. Litigious society. Number of litigations as it tries of the use of the judicial system.
|